Is This Really The Reason for Jim Thomson's Disappearance?

fountainhall
Posts: 895
Joined: Fri Jan 27, 2017 11:45 am
Location: Bangkok
Liked: 88 times
Been liked: 266 times

#1 Is This Really The Reason for Jim Thomson's Disappearance?

Postby fountainhall » Thu Dec 07, 2017 12:06 pm

Alerted by a reader of another forum, last night I attended the showing of the new documentary movie about Jim Thomson's disappearance exactly 50 years ago. Held at the Foreign Correspondents' Club of Thailand near Chidlom, the film puts forward what it calls a new and definitive explanation for this most intriguing of mysteries.

I found the documentary rather boring. It rehashes a lot of old material, goes over his early life as a partisan fighter in France and then working as a member of the OSS in Asia (the forerunner of the CIA), how he fell in love with Thailand, re-started the Thai silk industry and with his natural salesman's touch quickly made it a worldwide success - much to the annoyance of several other Thai-based silk industrialists. We knew of his sudden trip to a part of Malaysia's Cameron Highlands which was the centre of the remnants of the Malayan Communist Party. After more than a week staying with friends, he walked out of the cottage without his jacket, his cigarettes and his medicine - and totally disappeared.

According to the movie, Thomson had gone on that walk for a meeting which had been finally been set up with the leader of that communist insurgency, Chin Peng. It's often forgotten that even after Independence the mainly Chinese communists in Malaysia continued their activities until 1989. For a time they had the backing of Beijing and it was known that Chin Peng had met Chinese leaders in the early 1960s who believed that Malaysia was ripe for conversion to communism. But why that would be of specific interest to Thomson has never been clarified.

The movie, using as sources mostly the children of those involved, some of whom attended the discussion session after the movie last night, suggests that the objective of the meeting was not to meet Chin Peng. It was to enlist his help in spiriting Thomson to Cambodia where he would meet with an exiled former Prime Minister of Thailand, Pridi Banomyong. Pridi had also been Regent during the final years of the young King Ananda who was studying in Switzerland. After Pridi engineered a failed coup in 1949, he fled to China and would never return. By the 1960s under King Norodom Sihanouk, Cambodia maintained close relations with China. Pridi was thus able to move with relative freedom between China and Cambodia. On the other hand, with the Vietnam War underway, it was extremely difficult for Thais to travel across the border into a Cambodia that was in cahoots with communist China.

Pridi allegedly wished to meet a senior Thai official. For whatever reason, that official decided not to make the trip and Thomson was asked to go in his place. That much appears to be fact. He agreed. Whilst waiting in Malaysia there is no doubt that he would have been closely watched by Chin Peng’s guerillas. No doubt also they would have delved into his past and discovered that he had been – and perhaps still was – involved in the CIA. Wanting nothing to do with a possible American spy, during Thomson’s sudden walk from the cottage he was ambushed by the guerillas, taken by truck to some unknown destination, killed and buried in the jungle.

The film makes a more convincing theory than most but without enough real facts to back it all up. If someone could find out why Pridi wanted to meet a senior official of the Thai government 18 years after fleeing, this would have made it much more believable. As it was, a number of correspondents present were not convinced.

PeterUK
Posts: 217
Joined: Sun Aug 08, 2010 11:51 am
Liked: 41 times
Been liked: 83 times

#2 Re: Is This Really The Reason for Jim Thomson's Disappearance?

Postby PeterUK » Tue Dec 19, 2017 10:06 am

By temperament I incline to accidental rather than conspiratorial theories of the deaths of famous people. Famous people aren't immune from accidents! After reading William Warren's book about Jim Thompson, I concluded that the most likely cause of death was that he wandered from the main path and fell into an animal trap prepared by local tribesmen and died. When they realised what had happened the tribesmen buried him there, fearing retribution. We'll probably never know for certain what happened but that theory will do for me for now.

fountainhall
Posts: 895
Joined: Fri Jan 27, 2017 11:45 am
Location: Bangkok
Liked: 88 times
Been liked: 266 times

#3 Re: Is This Really The Reason for Jim Thomson's Disappearance?

Postby fountainhall » Tue Dec 19, 2017 11:29 pm

PeterUK wrote:After reading William Warren's book about Jim Thompson, I concluded that the most likely cause of death was that he wandered from the main path and fell into an animal trap prepared by local tribesmen and died.

I have not read the book but the movie did discuss this possibility. One problem thrown up is that the Malaysian police used three tracker dogs in their searches. They tracked his scent part way from the bungalow but then lost it. That seems to indicate he could not have gone off track into the jungle. Admittedly this idea does not hold a lot of water, given that he had been up and down that road just a few hours before his disappearance.

Thomson was a very pragmatic character. Given all the circumstances of his Malaysian visit, he definitely seems to have been on a mission of some nature. He knew the area and the road. During his stay at what had once been the HQ of the Malayan Communist Party, it is known he was under continuous communist surveillance. Given the intensity of the official searches over 11 full days with over 500 people involved including army, police, British servicemen, trekkers and fortune hunters, had he fallen into an animal trap relatively close to that road, my view is his body must certainly have been found. I agree with the movie's conclusion that he had to have been whisked away from the relatively immediate area in a motor vehicle by some person/s who knew him and whom he assumed would help him in whatever mission he was on. Thereafter, who knows?


Return to “Everything Else”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: Bing [Bot] and 8 guests